well from looking at your pictures yes I can see you were cut tight. I was cut tight as well. as for your skin being to "thin" well without actually seeing it in person... I doubt it. Most US doctors know very little about the function of the foreskin and it's structures. and VERY few and I mean VERY few know anything about restoration, methods of restoration, and the benefits of restoring.

surgical restoration should be the LAST resort. there are other ways to restore your foreskin. look for a book... it's called "The Joy of Circumcising" by John Bigalow. it might be hard to find but is a good read. it has helped me and many of my friends who are also restoring